Precision Vehicle Challenge: KTCA Rubric
Knowledge, Thinking, Communication, and Application are each worth 25%.
Assessment uses the complete body of evidence: the design plan, annotated sketch, prototype, observed tool use, troubleshooting, peer feedback, revisions, testing data, final explanation, and each studentβs individual Notion entries.
Important
Performance matters, but the closest vehicle does not automatically earn the highest grade. Technical understanding, safe work, purposeful problem solving, reliable evidence, and meaningful improvement are assessed even when a vehicle does not reach the target successfully.
| Level | General meaning |
|---|---|
| 1 β Limited | Important understanding or evidence is missing, inaccurate, or requires substantial support. |
| 2 β Some | Partial achievement is evident, but important gaps or inconsistencies remain. |
| 3 β Considerable | Clear, accurate, and consistent achievement of the project expectations. |
| 4 β Thorough | Precise, insightful, effective, and independent achievement that extends beyond the expected standard. |
Knowledge and Understanding β 25%
Propulsion, wheels, axles, friction, alignment, mechanical terminology, safety, and testing procedures
| Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 | Level 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Explains few mechanical ideas accurately. Uses limited terminology and needs substantial support to describe safe tool use or the testing procedure. | Shows partial understanding of the main systems. Some explanations or terms are accurate, but misconceptions or gaps affect decisions. Describes most safety and testing steps. | Clearly explains how propulsion, wheels, axles, friction, alignment, and chassis design affect performance. Uses suitable terminology and follows safe, standardized procedures. | Explains system interactions precisely and uses technical terminology independently. Connects mechanical principles, safety, and testing controls to specific design and performance decisions. |
Thinking β 25%
Planning, success criteria, problem analysis, test decisions, evidence-based improvement, and justification
| Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 | Level 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Planning is incomplete or weakly connected to construction. Identifies few problems or makes changes with little evidence or justification. | Creates a basic plan and recognizes obvious problems. Attempts testing and improvement, but evidence or reasoning is inconsistent. | Creates a practical, measured plan with useful criteria. Identifies likely causes of problems, uses test evidence and feedback, and justifies purposeful improvements. | Anticipates constraints, compares alternatives, and uses well-controlled evidence to diagnose interacting problems. Improvements are strategic, clearly justified, and evaluated thoughtfully. |
Communication β 25%
Annotated sketches, dimensions, terminology, photographs, test tables, peer feedback, explanations, and Notion documentation
| Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 | Level 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sketches or entries are incomplete, vague, or difficult to follow. Important dimensions, photographs, data, feedback, or explanations are missing. | Communicates the main idea with some useful evidence, but technical detail, organization, specificity, or individual explanation is inconsistent. | Uses clear annotated sketches, accurate dimensions, labelled photographs, organized data, suitable terminology, and specific daily explanations to make the process understandable. | Selects and organizes precise evidence into a highly clear technical account. Before-and-after comparisons, data, feedback responses, and explanations reveal how and why the design changed. |
Application β 25%
Safe tool and material use, construction, functionality, implementation of improvements, and standardized testing
| Level 1 | Level 2 | Level 3 | Level 4 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Uses tools or materials with limited control and frequent support. The prototype or testing process is incomplete, and planned improvements are minimally implemented. | Uses most tools and materials appropriately. The prototype functions inconsistently or has unresolved construction issues. Some improvements and testing steps are completed. | Works safely and purposefully. Builds a functioning prototype, implements meaningful improvements, and completes three controlled trials with accurate measurement. | Demonstrates precise, efficient, and independent fabrication. Improvements noticeably strengthen performance or reliability, and testing is executed with exceptional control and care. |
Evidence check
- Labelled initial sketch with important measurements
- Initial success criteria and performance goal
- Construction and progress photographs
- Mechanical problem analysis
- Peer feedback and individual response
- Annotated design review and final improvement plan
- Before-and-after evidence
- Three-trial results table and calculations
- Final explanation and individual reflection